Sally or Amy?

[Shotgun da ferret]

You know a question hit me about sometime ago when I was reading Sonic comics and watching Sonic X at the same time. If it all came down to choosing Amy or Princess Sally, who would Sonic choose. Not just in the comics or show or the games but overall. I need some input from you guys cause I seem to be lost in pondering this boone.

[Ziggy]

well he would pik prencess sally ofcourse becuzz he dont really like Amy but in the old days he liked sally .............but the sad thing is, sally left but i didnt read that comic

[Steel Valor]

I dunno Shots. This is a good question. I think Sonic should go for Princess Sally because every hero needs a damsel in distress that he eventually falls in love with. But thats just me.

[Ziggy]

I dunno Shots. This is a good question. I think Sonic should go for Princess Sally because every hero needs a damsel in distress that he eventually falls in love with. But thats just me.

I agree Dude and acually he really does Fall in love With Her

[Shotgun da ferret]

But then what about Amy? Amy and Sonic have alot in common. And we always like to see people playing hard to get.

[Ziggy]

But then what about Amy? Amy and Sonic have alot in common. And we always like to see people playing hard to get.

True and in a way he probly likes Amy but in the show he realy like Sally but he ran away from Amy

[Espio]

If ya think about it Sally and Amy are just about the same. They both have a liking for Sonic and are so close but Sonic then changes his mind and then switches to someone else.

[Steel Valor]

I'm gonna be laughing one day when they start fighting

[Tails 4ever]

I think Sonic should be single. In the comics I read (the English ones) Amy was a tomboy and actually lost her crush on him as the series continued - they had more of a brother-sister relationship. But if I had to choose, it'd be Sally - mostly because I'm a Shadow/Amy fan anyways.

[Steel Valor]

What I never understood is....How can Amy and Shadow have a relationship? Shadow and Rouge seems better. Lets face it, Amy is too hyper to be Shad's girl.

[Black Knight]

Rouge and Shadow would never happen....It doesn't take a genius to realise that if Sonic Adventure 2 hadn't been rated for kids then Knuckles and Rouge would of shagged the livin' light out of each other in that scen after their battle.

Shadow would not get with Maria either cause they were best friends, not lovers or Amy either for that matter...just, no.

Personally I always liked Mina getting with Sonic more(then again I haven't read all of the comics), but thats most likely cause I read the part where Mina meets Sonic for the first time, how she joins the Freedom Fighters, how she sees Sally and Sonic say they love each other and finally how she takes a bullet for Sally because Sonic loves her.
Now thats love folks...And I could of probably been mistaken for a fountain while reading the part where she takes the bullet.

Eversince that I've had something of a hate attitude towards Sally, I mainly see her as a posh princess trying to be cool, but then again I haven't fully read(and probably never will, because Sweden sucks) the comics.

I'd say Amy, because I think she'd fit best with Sonic...I mean, think about it...Sonic is a cool guy, but there's no way in hell that he's cut out to be King...He needs a tom-boyish girl who ain't gonna tie him down.

Edit: I think that means I win =P

[Steel Valor]

Ok I understand the Sonic X Amy point of view and sort of kind of understand Sonic X Mina. Explain that relationship a little more.

[Black Knight]

Can't really explain Mina x Sonic anymore then I have. I haven't read all of the comics, mainly round the part where she takes a bullet for Sally.

[Bazooka the Ferret]

I thought that was I kinda cool and kinda stupid at the same time. I'm pretty sure could've dodged it in time, after all he is the fastest thing alive.

[Sparky]

Did Mina die? I haven't seen her around. And she jumped in front of the bullet that was aimed for Sally, right?
Sonic x Amy. I agree with all that Black Knight said.

((Random: I just heard a bump and my sister groan really loud. Lol I think she stubbed her toe... xD))

[Hero]

SallyXSonic.

Amy's voice and personality irritates me and makes me think of every other high school girl I have to come in contact with. Sally takes charge and acts like a natural born leader.

Yay for tomboy chipmunks.

[Steel Valor]

lol tomboyish chipmunks. I wouldn't say Amy is like a highschool girl because then she would say "like" too much. I would picture more like Japanese school girl like Hinata from Love Hina

[Hero]

Even worse... girly girls irritate me and Amy is one of those extreme girly girls. I mean, it's not the fact that she's pink (pink is my favorite color, btw) but she's just... stupid, to be honest. I can't ever picture her and Sonic getting together, no matter what happens (Sally dying, Sonic finally thinking he should settle down [lolwut], etc) but she holds onto that thought like a life preserver.

Girls all too often hold onto a thought that's obsolete or dead or impossible (I even do it) but she takes it to the max and it just annoys me to the point where I hate her character because she acts so ignorant at times.

Sorry if I uh... offended anyone. >_> Just my thoughts on Amy.

[Shotgun da ferret]

Even worse... girly girls irritate me and Amy is one of those extreme girly girls. I mean, it's not the fact that she's pink (pink is my favorite color, btw) but she's just... stupid, to be honest. I can't ever picture her and Sonic getting together, no matter what happens (Sally dying, Sonic finally thinking he should settle down [lolwut], etc) but she holds onto that thought like a life preserver.

Girls all too often hold onto a thought that's obsolete or dead or impossible (I even do it) but she takes it to the max and it just annoys me to the point where I hate her character because she acts so ignorant at times.

Sorry if I uh... offended anyone. >_> Just my thoughts on Amy.

I agree with you 100%.

[Black Knight]

I always thought that Amy was one of the few fun fangirls I've ever seen anywhere. oo

I think Amy was at her best in Sonic Adventure really...Sure she got caught, but in the end she managed to kick ass...

WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO HER PROMISE OF GETTING MORE INDEPENDENT?!?! D<
In the end of Sonic Adventure 1 she says that she's gonna impress Sonic through being more indepent, yet nothing changes!

If SEGA actually made something of that promise Amy would be cool! D>

[Sparky]

I always thought that Amy was one of the few fun fangirls I've ever seen anywhere. oo

I think Amy was at her best in Sonic Adventure really...Sure she got caught, but in the end she managed to kick ass...

WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO HER PROMISE OF GETTING MORE INDEPENDENT?!?! D<
In the end of Sonic Adventure 1 she says that she's gonna impress Sonic through being more indepent, yet nothing changes!

If SEGA actually made something of that promise Amy would be cool! D>

In my opinion, Sonic Adventure kinda stunk. And not just like dirty socks, but like... a milk carton left in your locker for the summer. The graphics, especially. At least they give you free gold and silver chao for breeding a transparent one when you transfer it to SAB2!!!
*agrees at all of the above*
Let's not forget how she made Shadow cry. =P

[Ziggy]

I always thought that Amy was one of the few fun fangirls I've ever seen anywhere. oo

I think Amy was at her best in Sonic Adventure really...Sure she got caught, but in the end she managed to kick ass...

WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO HER PROMISE OF GETTING MORE INDEPENDENT?!?! D<
In the end of Sonic Adventure 1 she says that she's gonna impress Sonic through being more indepent, yet nothing changes!

If SEGA actually made something of that promise Amy would be cool! D>

you are super.. no, Mega Right about that.
I would actually use Amy if she didn't Worry about Sonic so Freakin much.

[Black Knight]

In my opinion, Sonic Adventure kinda stunk. And not just like dirty socks, but like... a milk carton left in your locker for the summer. The graphics, especially. At least they give you free gold and silver chao for breeding a transparent one when you transfer it to SAB2!!!
*agrees at all of the above*
Let's not forget how she made Shadow cry. =P

1. I'm quite interested in hearing about what you disliked about he game, appart from the graphics, I seriously find blaming the graphics to be a pathetic reason.

2. Read above on my oppinion on that.

Oh, Shadow needed a good cry. Everyone does after a dear friend dies =O


you are super.. no, Mega Right about that.
I would actually use Amy if she didn't Worry about Sonic so Freakin much.

We can agree on that then. SEGA should get a grip and make her fullfill her promise! She'd be like Sakura! Go from annoying to dead cool....Seriously think she could be really cool if they made her mature a bit...

[Steel Valor]

True, but SEGA has been known to make a couple of mistakes sometimes. A lot of mistakes. IF Amy was to become like Sakura then that would be copying Naruto. What should happen is that Amy is put through some sort of mental trial that would make her more independent and less stupid.

[Ziggy]

well.. Now the deal about Sally....
She the best period. If was sonic I would so Marry her.
but then again I wouldn't.

[Black Knight]

True, but SEGA has been known to make a couple of mistakes sometimes. A lot of mistakes. IF Amy was to become like Sakura then that would be copying Naruto. What should happen is that Amy is put through some sort of mental trial that would make her more independent and less stupid.

Thats pretty much what I meant, but phrased it differently.
I meant that she matures like Sakura have, not necessarily in the same way. I just meant that she'd be like Sakura in the way that she'd go from Anniying to Cool if she did get more independent.

[Sparky]

1. I'm quite interested in hearing about what you disliked about he game, appart from the graphics, I seriously find blaming the graphics to be a pathetic reason.

I wasn't totally blaming the sucky-ness on just the graphics.

Oh, Shadow needed a good cry. Everyone does after a dear friend dies =O

I wouldn't necessarily call that a "good" cry. More like a held back tear because you couldn't take it any more.
If you think about it, if Gerald was Shadow's dad (his creator, y'know?) and Maria was Gerald's niece, then Maria would be Shadow's cousin. Right? Just a random thought. =P

[Oscar!2000]

i think Amy and Shadow don't make a good couple

[Black Knight]

1. I'm quite interested in hearing about what you disliked about he game, appart from the graphics, I seriously find blaming the graphics to be a pathetic reason.

I wasn't totally blaming the sucky-ness on just the graphics.

Oh, Shadow needed a good cry. Everyone does after a dear friend dies =O

I wouldn't necessarily call that a "good" cry. More like a held back tear because you couldn't take it any more.
If you think about it, if Gerald was Shadow's dad (his creator, y'know?) and Maria was Gerald's niece, then Maria would be Shadow's cousin. Right? Just a random thought. =P

Check a little closer of what I ask next time...I asked why, not for you to defend yourself against a claim that wasn't even directed to you, it was a general saying.

And the last part was more jokingly, but yeah, you're correct that Shadow and Maria would be 'cousins' in that case.

i think Amy and Shadow don't make a good couple

But on the actually subject of the topic with is AmyxSonic or SallyxSonic, what would your oppinion be?

[Sparky]

Check a little closer of what I ask next time...I asked why, not for you to defend yourself against a claim that wasn't even directed to you, it was a general saying.

Okay. Well... hmm... most of the sucky-ness was of the graphics, but other than that, I found that the personalities didn't match the characters. The voice for Knuckles didn't sound like I would have expected it to be. I picture him an African American, if I may say so (he's kind of like the stereotypical) - The dreadlocks, the voice, [in other games] his style, and that his theme song is rap. Erm... Amy didn't keep her promise as said before, the robot [I found] didn't have really any reason to capture Amy, E102's voice in the other games didn't sound real, and they left out Rouge and Shadow. And they should have included Cream. I have yet to find a reason, though. o.o;;


And the last part was more jokingly, but yeah, you're correct that Shadow and Maria would be 'cousins' in that case.

Yeah, I know. =P
Shadow is a senior citizen. Assuming that he's 16, then he's 66 right now. But, actually, if he ages like humans, he's actually 19 or 20, considering the fact that I celebrate Shadow's birthday every year. It's on June 19, for the folkies that care.

[Black Knight]

Okay. Well... hmm... most of the sucky-ness was of the graphics, but other than that, I found that the personalities didn't match the characters.

Oh? I really didn't notice that, care to explain more? If it's something I've missed I sure wouldn't mind hearing. ^^


The voice for Knuckles didn't sound like I would have expected it to be. I picture him an African American, if I may say so (he's kind of like the stereotypical) - The dreadlocks, the voice, his style, and that his theme song is rap.

[I]No, just no! If they made him anymore after the afro-american stereotype he'd soon have a load of hip hopping dumbasses demanding that he will act all 'gangstah'.


Erm... Amy didn't keep her promise as said before

That is not as much a fault in the game as it is a fault made by SEGA. She says it in the very end so the proof of her being more independent should of shown in Sonic Adventure 2, which is partly does as she and Tails are the ones that bust Sonic out of prison island.


the robot didn't have really any reason to capture Amy,

[I]Once again I have to disagree. She was protecting the bird, thus the robot had to grab Amy to get too the bird.


E102's voice in the other games didn't sound real,

What other games? E102 Gamma dies in the end of Sonic Adventure, so he doesn't appear in any other games...Unless you have somekind of mass theory on 123 Omega being Gamma rebuilt.(which would be impossible as Gamma was blown to bits)


and they left out Rouge and Shadow.

All I'll say is Sonic Adventure and Sonic Adventure 2


And they should have included Cream. I have yet to find a reason, though. o.o;;

Cream wouldn'f of added anything to the story, thus she would of been useless. But she is in the game, she does a cameo.


Shadow is a senior citizen. Assuming that he's 16, then he's 66 right now. But, actually, if he ages like humans, he's actually 19 or 20, considering the fact that I celebrate Shadow's birthday every year. It's on June 19, for the folkies that care.

Actually, if we go after human years he'd be 6 years old...if you count from when the game was released.[/quote]

[Sparky]

Oh? I really didn't notice that, care to explain more? If it's something I've missed I sure wouldn't mind hearing. ^^

Knuckles isn't as gullible in the other games, and Sonic could have just run away from Amy when they went to Twinkle Park Couples Night or something. He could have run away a lot of times, actually...

No, just no! If they made him anymore after the afro-american stereotype he'd soon have a load of hip hopping dumbasses demanding that he will act all 'gangstah'.

I don't quite understand what you mean.

That is not as much a fault in the game as it is a fault made by SEGA. She says it in the very end so the proof of her being more independent should of shown in Sonic Adventure 2, which is partly does as she and Tails are the ones that bust Sonic out of prison island.

That is my point.

Once again I have to disagree. She was protecting the bird, thus the robot had to grab Amy to get too the bird.

But he's more powerful than Amy, so really all he had to do was grab the bird. Eh, forget it.

What other games? E102 Gamma dies in the end of Sonic Adventure, so he doesn't appear in any other games...Unless you have somekind of mass theory on 123 Omega being Gamma rebuilt.(which would be impossible as Gamma was blown to bits)

What I meant was that his voice sounded a lot different than the other times I heard it. I can't really name all of the games that he's been in.

All I'll say is Sonic Adventure and Sonic Adventure 2

Whoopsies. Hmm... well, I mean, they could have put Rouge in earlier and then Eggman would have another sidekick. Even though that game was pretty much non-dark...

Cream wouldn'f of added anything to the story, thus she would of been useless. But she is in the game, she does a cameo.

She could have fit in there. Big didn't really have a purpose, did he? I forget if he tied in with the others somehow. Cream and Big could have partnered up.

Actually, if we go after human years he'd be 6 years old...if you count from when the game was released.

Um... alright. I meant from the age on the game, plus the years that he's been around.

[Black Knight]

Knuckles isn't as gullible in the other games, and Sonic could have just run away from Amy when they went to Twinkle Park Couples Night or something. He could of run away a lot of times, actually...

Knuckles wasn't anymore gullible then he normally is. It's in his personality to be naive, even in Sonic X he gets tricked by Eggman.
He gets tricked by Eggman saying that Sonic is after the Master Emerald and Sonic is refusing to give the emeralds,(which Knuckles still thinks is ME shards) of course he's gonna believe it even more.


I don't quite understand what you mean.

You said afro-american, which is the rapper/ghetto/gangster stereotype. But as you seemed to have no idea about what I meant when I said gangster, I do believe what you meant is the Jamacian stereotype.


That is my point.

If thats your point then how you point that out as a fault of the game?
If it's SEGA that AFTER the game make another game where her promise isn't fullfilled that isn't a fault of the game that's a fault of SEGA.


But he's more powerful than Amy, so really all he had to do was grab the bird. Eh, forget it.

But she's quicker too, thus she managed to run and the theory of him being stronger is not correct as you have to beat him to beat her story.


What I meant was that his voice sounded a lot different than the other times I heard it. I can't really name all of the games that he's been in.

Cause he ISN'T in any other games, it's impossible, completly and utterly impossible. He's created in the start of Sonic Adventure and dies in the end, he's a one game character, thus there is NO WAY AT ALL that he could be in any other game.


Whoopsies. Hmm... well, I mean, they could have put Rouge in earlier and then Eggman would have another sidekick. Even though that game was pretty much non-dark...

Rouge didn't exist when they made Sonic Adventure, thus they couldn't of done what you ask. Once again not a fault of the game.


She could have fit in there. Big didn't really have a purpose, did he? I forget if he tied in with the others somehow. Cream and Big could have partnered up.

Then again, Big is in the game cause his friend Froggy gets possessed by Chaos' tail and also swallows one of the emeralds.
While Cream have NO connection to the plot at all...unless they made Cheese get possessed by Chaos' tail and made him swallow a chaos emerald...could of worked, but for this they wanted Big it seems. (Most likely because his gameplay was so different to the others)


Um... alright. I meant from the age on the game, plus the years that he's been around.

The years he's been around?

[Espio]

:eek:Okay guys lets get back onto the topic here. If you want to post a Sonic Adventure section in Sonic games.:cool:

[Ziggy]

:eek:Okay guys lets get back onto the topic here. If you want to post a Sonic Adventure section in Sonic games.:cool:

Yeah...Back on topic.....
Off topic:Espio I've noticed that you rarley talk in the Shout box....Why?:o

[Steel Valor]

Seriously guys, have you noticed that Amy brings Sonic down sometimes. Take SA2 for instance, she was captured by Eggman and nearly got Sonic killed? I mean sure it made the storyline somewhat cooler but still it was kinda stupid the way she got captured. It was very typical.

[Ziggy]

I've never played SA2. But I can Imagine how dumb she got caught.

[Roxas_the_hedgehog]

ive played it to. dont forget sonic riders when eggman was trying to open the babylon door.

[Kursed]

Seriously guys, have you noticed that Amy brings Sonic down sometimes. Take SA2 for instance, she was captured by Eggman and nearly got Sonic killed? I mean sure it made the storyline somewhat cooler but still it was kinda stupid the way she got captured. It was very typical.

That was a bit of a shock when I first saw that

[Ziggy]

ive played it to. dont forget sonic riders when eggman was trying to open the babylon door.

I've played sonic riders....
and now that I think of it...It was stupid how she was caught.:o

[Shadeam]

What I never understood is....How can Amy and Shadow have a relationship? Shadow and Rouge seems better. Lets face it, Amy is too hyper to be Shad's girl.
No, Rouge likes Knuckles, remember? Sonic WOULD pick Sally, if it were his decision, and Amy would probably get on with her life after she kills sonic with her Piko-Piko hammer.

[Antony the Bat]

Well Amy Rose is cute but my vote would go for Princess Sally Acorn because she is not obsessed with Sonic the Hedgehog even when Sally Acorn is the leader of Knothole Freedom Fighters.

[I_Luv_Tails]

Sally hands down. Besides, Sonic actually likes her back.

[Black Knight]

Neither, Sonic would NEVER be fit to marry a princess and he knows so and he views Amy as that annoying little sister if anything...

I'd go for Mina, but she gets together with some guy called Ash, if I don't remember incorrectly.

[Shackel11]

Neither. Both are annoying, just Amy is more annoying.

[DarknessTheDarkHedgehog]

[Maybe Princess Elise LOL (joke)]

I think Sonic will Pike Princess Sally cause he've known her from a long time....[I guess]:cool:

And Black Knight, you might be SO Right..

[Black Knight]

My point is that Sonic is a freedom loving guy and if he married Sally, who'll be a Queen after her mother and father steps down from the throne, he would King...could Sonic(I mean, being serious) EVER be King material?

I think not!

[Ziggy]

Uh...We're talking about which girl best fits, not who he should be with. =/

Anyway, like I said earlier. Sally is a better girl for Sonic, because Amy is an annoying, pink stalker.....
end of story.

[Black Knight]

Mina should be added to the ranks in that case

And that's who he fits best with.
Why? Cause she's indepedent, she's a fighter, she's carefree, she's cheerful, she's speedy.
She's just perfect for him...

Amy would be second best, especially if she got some indepence.
Why? Cause she's somewhat independent, sure she can be demanding, but not enough to tie Sonic down. She's pretty cheerful and sweet and when she wants to be, smart and helpful. She's a normal girl, getting with her wouldn't tie him down.

And Sally would be least best.
Why? Not because I think she's a bad person, but because she's a princess, he wouldn't cope with the royal life. She's meant to be the future queen, which she has accepted(as far as I can see) and Sonic would just not be ready to accept a life like that, not until he's like...70 years old and starting to get grey fur.

[Steel Valor]

BK is a fighter lol.


Even though Mina is somewhat of a mirror of Sonic. Sonic has been known in the past to be a great leader, both the games and of the comics exhibit this. Do you think Sonic would still have a freedom loving attitude if he decided to settle down with someone and raise a family? I don't think so, IMO, instead he would start to become responsible and considerate. The only reason Sonic is free like the wind is because he's a teenager. He craves action and needs some sort of restriction on his behavior. Sally is that restriction, ever heard of "opposites attract"

What's my point?


Well the way I see it is that Sonic could be made to rule by Sally's side. Obviously the two have the most romantic history together. They worked alongside each other in the fields of battle. And not to mention every man needs a headstrong woman to rule his heart. My apologies if I seem blunt, but Mina can't cope with Sonic's heroic duties unlike Sally who has been enduring it for quite some time. Mina was never made to be a Freedom Fighter, she never really supported Sonic either. Besides she left him for that one guy...What's his name? Ash? Apparently those two have been getting along pretty well. Sally unlike Sonic, is careful and make sure what she knows what she's getting into. Sonic on the otherhand rushes recklessly into things. These two opposites are the reason why they click together so easily.

Am I wrong?

[Black Knight]

I base my oppinion on what I've seen, and as Sweden sucks and doesn't sell the comic, that isn't a hell of a load.

What I DO know though is that Ash only enters the picture AFTER Mina gets heart broken from seeing Sally and Sonic kiss, saying they love each other, AND after she takes a bullet for Sally because Sonic loves her(Sally that is), thus taking the bullet cause she realises that Sally has Sonic's heart and she wants Sonic to be happy.

Anyway, getting AWAY from the sob scens I do see what you're coming from, but we're talking about Sonic right here and now, what would OUR Sonic(the carefree, adventurous loving and speedy buggah) fit with?

I'd say Mina

And on second thought,(Also Steels good explanation on what Sally is like) second Sally and last Amy.

But apparently Archie Comics thinks differently to me as Sonic has been paired with Sally...

[Eileanach]

I'd say that Sonic would pick Princess Sally. Mainly because Princess Sally is meant to be nearer his age than Amy is. Amy has a little fangirly crush on Sonic and will eventually grow out of it. Sonic doesn't help much by seeming to play hard to get. Sally on the other hand has a hold over Sonic she can actually affect how he makes decisions. So I'd say Sally is a better choice really.

[Shotgun da ferret]

How about we rename this thread to Sonic's relationships. But wasn't Sally, Sonic's first love? I mean, when you look at the stories of all the other girls, hers is the most intriguing, she matured the most.

[Eileanach]

Indeed I believe Sally was Sonic's first experience in women and thus first love experience. She always was a lot more level headed and mature in comparison to other characters Shots I agree. But her story now has only increased her maturity.

[Black Knight]

I know that this is kinda offtopic, but as it seems a lot of people here read the comics...Do any of you know any site I could buy them on or something?

I'm asking cause sweden is crap and don't sell the sonic comics ANYWHERE. =/

[Eileanach]

I believe E-bay sells quite a few of the comics. They are actually starting to Archive the comics as well if you check on the Archie site you will see that they have archives. I DID have a site were you could read them but I lost it when I re-fixed my PC. I'm sorry. BK.

[Black Knight]

Ah! Thank you! ^^

I believe this may be off topic, but at the same time not as I want to read the comics to get to know Sally more. =D

[Eileanach]

Sally is a pretty cool character in the comics. You will maybe end up thinking that she and Sonic actually do suit being together. The archie comic is kind of a continuation of SatAM and some of the games that got released more recently... because Shadow and Silver etc are in some of them. It's odd but quite nicely done.

[Segan]

Though I do sincerely wish this entire topic would fall off a bridge, I will grace it with two seconds of my time.

Even IF I despise the way Amy looks as well as her "Sonic's just jealous because he can't hear the voices" psychotic personality, with some minor adjustment I'd pick her over Sally. Why? 3 Reasons.

1. Most people who play Sonic are familiar with Amy, whereas any knowledge of Sally lies in the deep, dark, back alleys of the internet.

B. Amy debuted in Sonic CD. So did Metal. Sonic CD was awesome. So was Metal. That's a two out of three right there.

and finally,
III: Sonic + Sally is cross-species, and technically, bestiality.

Let's not forget that Sally's starred in about zero games while Amy's been in nearly all of them. And personally, retro Amy wins over both of them.

[E-123 Omega]

I have t agree on SOME of the things stegblob said. And I too think Amy is the best chioce for sonic.

[Nekiko]

Even though I'm a SonAmy fan, if Sonic actually chose a girl, it'd be Sally. She was the only girl he ever showed romantic feelings towards.

However, it's confusing... since Sally and Sonic have zero relatioship in the games, and Sonic and Amy have little to no relationship in the comics (just from what I've heard; I never read them).

If it were to go only on the Sonic we know in the games up to this point... he'd probably pick neither and just run like hell to get away from there... xD

[Espio]

Im sorry Nekiko but they never really show Sally to everyone..... I mean not everyone reads the comics and secondly i think Sonic would just fall for another hedgehog not a...... whatever Sally is.

[Black Knight]

Sally is a squirell. And I live in a country where they don't even sell the comics and I know who sally is. Jesus, if you do a little searching you can find alot of info on her, like here!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sally_Acorn

If we go by the games it'd have to be Amy as she's the only female character(appart from Rouge) that is in that series.

If we go by the Archie comics, then it's Sally, cause he's already been together with her before, unless he gets a sudden change of heart.

[Espio]

I know who Sally is. I just don't really see it happening.

[Super_Sonic_Alex]

You know a question hit me about sometime ago when I was reading Sonic comics and watching Sonic X at the same time. If it all came down to choosing Amy or Princess Sally, who would Sonic choose. Not just in the comics or show or the games but overall. I need some input from you guys cause I seem to be lost in pondering this boone.


:cool: He would pick sally! I know it.

[DarknessTheDarkHedgehog]

My point is that Sonic is a freedom loving guy and if he married Sally, who'll be a Queen after her mother and father steps down from the throne, he would King...could Sonic(I mean, being serious) EVER be King material?

I think not!


Yup, Thats what I mean Black Knight :cool:

[Black Knight]

As Sally apparently has no duty to become Queen now though, as her older brother steps up and takes his birth right as heir, it's just a question of if he'll get back together with Sally...

However, I have to agree, after doing closer research on Sally(which is reading Wiki xD) that Sonic would fit best with her.

[Espio]

Y'know you can never trust Wiki all the time.... Amy just seems that she would be perfect for Sonic.

[Black Knight]

Aye, but that article seems pretty acurate as they even get pieces of the comic to show it.

And seeing the personality they describe there(which fits the bill of what has been described here) she would fit better because she's more independent and more like and and not like Sonic at the same time.

[Antony the Bat]

Well Amy Rose is cute but I vote for Sally Acorn because she helps Sonic to lead the knothole Freedom fighters.

[Eileanach]

BK I am glad that you were able to read up a little on Sally and have come over to the Sally-side of thinking =D

[Antony the Bat]

Sonic would fall in love with Sally Acorn because Amy Rose is too obsessed with Sonic and Sonic rather be friends with Amy Rose than being Amy Roses boyfriend.

[Shadeam]

The true awnser is the comics ain't canon, so Sonic would be forced with Amy beacause Sally is just a damsel in distress in the actual games.

[Black Knight]

The true answer is that he didn't ask who was canon or not.

He(the creator of this thread) asked who Sonic would choose, who would fit best with him.

[Antony the Bat]

Well because Amy Rose forces Sonic to choose Sally Acorn would be the perfect girl for Sonic because Sally Acorn can cook Sonic some Chilli Dogs for lunch.

[Day]

You already posted in here.

Twice. That right there, is your third post repeating the same thing, and is proof of your lack of general intelligence.

For fuck's sake, stop posting.

[Antony the Bat]

Well if Amy Rose was not so obsessed with Sonic she would get her chance to date Sonic but it would happen only if Sonic says so.

[Black Knight]

Aye, which is stating the obvious.

[Natla of Atlantis]

I actually always wanted Sonic and Amy to get together, they would make a cute couple, but it seems like Sonic is leaning towards Sally, but I can live.

I just always saw them together. It kind of reminds me of Pucca and Garu, she's always chasing him, and ever so often, well, rarely, he'll show affection back. Maybe Amy is kinda fooling herself.

But I think if she got with Sonic she would eventually get burned out because she isn't really chasing him anymore. Then it would show if they would stay or not. So yeah. If that made any sense.

[Antony the Bat]

I think Sonic and Amy Rose do make a cute couple but for it to work Amy Rose needs to lower her obsession of marrying Sonic and concertrate on impressing Sonic by defeating his worst enemy Dr Eggman without anybodies help.

[Eileanach]

I don't think Sonic would lover her purely for defeating Robotnik/Eggman to be honest...

I agree with Natla I think that if Amy and Sonic DID (which I hope doesn't happen) get together she would eventually tire because there is no "chase" anymore for her no thrill to it. So it would prove whether she would stay or not.

I still believe Sally is better for Sonic she's more grounding for his nature.

[Tgman12]

I want to say Amy but Sally just seems better, although the scenes I've seen from Sonic 06 Amy seems to be a little more mature.Though that sucks scince its one of the WORST Sonic game EVER and Amy then dicides to grows up.

[Steel Valor]

Do you have anything that can back that argument up sir? As well as improving your typing skills?

[Antony the Bat]

Well sorry to be disappointing but I have nothing to back me up from this arguement so I have decided to start send ing better stuff this friday which it is a surprise from me to you all.

Well since Amy fancies Sonic and Sonic fancies Sally it will be a difficult choice for me so who would you choose if you are in Sonics shoes.

Amy Rose is now going out with her own boyfriend and his name is Dexter.

[Day]

The characters don't fancy anyone. By closest approximation, Amy is the only choice, since the Archie universe is worthless, and every comic contains the same teenage drama. It's not even revelant to Sonic as a character, they're just using his namesake to push their shitty stories.

And you're still posting here Antony, after God knows how many times already. Please stop. It's just not funny anymore.

[BigK]

When I was a teen kid, I loved SatAM, Amy's the cliche' latch on girlfriend, so I'll go with Sally.

[Tizo The Hedgehog]

Nah I think Amy is better, I just likr her, I dunno why but I have some strange hate twoards Sally. So yeah... Amy it is!

[Sally Acorn]

I'm pretty that there are more Amy lovers around here, but I do respect you. As you might have figured out already, I'm a Sally fan. I like her better as a character and I like her better with Sonic. Amy is a sweet character too and I have nothing against her. But it just seems more to me that her obsessing with Sonic is a bit immature and kinda scary sometimes... But I gotta admit that Sonic and Amy does look cute toghether.

So even though I support Sally, I do also like Amy and I think that all the bashing between Sally and Amy fans is unnecessary and immature.

[Triple S3]

The picture in the title says it all... Amy Rose